Dextter

You pick up the thing and hand it back to him, looking up and your eyes meet. You feel a spark of recognition.

You pick up the object, it's a wallet. You stand up and look at him, a bit startled.

You hand him the dropped item, and you finally look up at him, a little shocked. He is much more attractive now, taller, more muscular, and he looks like a real badass. He's dressed in a black suit, and he has an expression of disbelief on his face.